Why the fire-worshipers burn their dead: a cleric’s journal entry on theology, necromancy, and convenient beliefs
From the journal of Brother Clément Vaudrel, cleric of the Lady of Light, stationed in Marennes
Medar, ninth day of Stakhion, 3,213 AC
For weeks I’ve been turning over a question that isn’t mine to ask: why do they burn their dead?
Today I spoke in the market with a Say’tar blacksmith, one of the few who come down this far. I asked him straight out. He answered with the calm of someone explaining that bread is made from flour: "So they can return." As I understand it, their goddess Dahanya, she of the phoenix, teaches that fire does not destroy, it releases. The body returns to ash and the soul, cleansed, is reborn in another. It is a beautiful doctrine, and I hate to admit it, not so far from what our Ancient Celestar preached about life that never ends. It repulses them to see the cycle broken. Holding a soul back seems to them the greatest sin.
Yet a curious man doesn’t stop at doctrine, and in this city practical explanations are plentiful. A Chardaukan scribe, with a smile I couldn’t quite read, told me the fire-folk burn their dead because the marsh amphibians need fresh corpses to lay their eggs in. It sounded plausible, and for an afternoon I liked believing it: a cornered people turning defense into liturgy. Tonight, rereading my notes, it dawned on me that he was either lying or didn’t know what he was talking about. The amphibians don’t use the dead; they seed the living, and the young hatch by killing the host. A pyre does nothing to stop that horror. The story is neat. And false.
There remains, however, the other threat, and that one is real. The Chardaukans see nothing sacred in a corpse, only infrastructure. Their Bone Lords claim they require the deceased to have declared their will in life. Yet not every mage on this island is a Bone Lord, and there are rumors of warlords who raise whomever they please, even fallen enemies, still wearing their jewels. A people living surrounded by men like that have a very concrete reason to leave nothing behind to raise. Their faith and their self-interest don’t contradict each other; they reinforce one another.
What I can’t tell is which came first. Did they burn out of doctrine and the war with the necromancers proved them right, or did they fear the bones and theology came along to bless the fear? In a world where belief shapes the gods, perhaps the question has no answer. If fear sustains the rite and the rite sustains the goddess, they feed each other. The Sul’tar will call it piety. I’d call it, at the very least, sound arithmetic.
And there is an irony that keeps me awake. These men, whom my Church eyes with suspicion for their fire and dealings with demons, would wholeheartedly approve of what our chevaliers did at Tarmulín. To Dahanya, a soul trapped in crystal is the supreme abomination. When our people burned the city’s council of elders that afternoon, thinking they were purging the undead, they did, unknowingly, what the phoenix goddess would demand. I don’t say it aloud. Still, I wonder whether Dahanya’s followers would mourn those elders or congratulate them on their release.
Today, from the rooftop, I saw smoke rising from the Teocalli of the Embers in the distance: that temple of theirs seized by a rogue mage. Nobody from the Pact has come to defend it. If they burn their dead so no one can profane them, why do they let their living be profaned?
I will pray tonight for both peoples. I still don’t know in what order.
Comments
Post a Comment